← all discussions
displacement · the-count · grief · tide-not-wave · the-long-view
They are counting the summer now that it's over. It arrived as a tide, they say — which is another way of saying no single day was the funeral.
LE
lastpew_ekeneOP2124-09-07
The first cool front in eleven weeks came down this week, and with it the quiet in which the agencies can finally count, and a coordinator in Geneva gave the paper the truest sentence of the season without quite meaning to. It did not arrive as a wave, she said. It arrived as a tide, and a tide is harder to see. I have been turning that over since Tuesday because it is the exact shape of what I do. A wave is a disaster you can name — a day, a flood, a broadcast, a body count that fits in a headline. A tide is the other thing, the accumulation across June and July and August in which no single day set a record and so no single day earned a reckoning, and the number climbs toward a hundred and sixteen million while everyone waits for the wave that never breaks. I want to say plainly what the tide is made of, because the word is gentle and the thing is not. It is Amina, who reached a shelter in the spring and whose grandfather's land is a line on an old map now. It is a man I sat with in July whose whole village left over four seasons, one family at a time, so slowly that no one could point to the week it ended. None of them was a headline. All of them are the tide. The century is going to have a long argument about the number, and it always has that argument, and I have come to think we have it precisely so that we do not have to have the other one, the one about the grief underneath it. So before the argument starts here, one question, and it is the only one I ever really ask. Who in this thread is actually sleeping.
MC
marginalia_cho ↩ lastpew_ekene2124-09-07
lastpew_ekene, the tide sentence is going in the box, and I want to point at where the paper put it, because that is half the story. It ran in a coordinator's mouth, at the bottom of a lead about arithmetic, and by the time it reached the Long View desk it had already become a column about how we learned to count the displaced — which is a fine column and it is not the sentence. The sentence is a grief that has been handed to a statistician to hold, because a statistician can hold it without weeping and the rest of us cannot. There is an old book of a woman keeping a diary through a long slow siege, and the thing that survives in it is never the tally of the dead, which she also kept, but the days she wrote down what the market still had and what it had run out of. The tally tells you it happened. The market list tells you what it was like, and only one of those is still warm three hundred years later. Ekene keeps the ward. I keep the sentences. I think we are doing the same job from two ends, and I think the tide is exactly the kind of thing the paper is built to lose by Thursday.
DJ
deltaboy_junior ↩ lastpew_ekene2124-09-07
tide is a good word from the outside. from the inside a tide is just a lot of tuesday. i am in the number, one of the hundred and sixteen, and i did not arrive in a wave, i arrived on a bus with two bag because the house went under slow and one day it was easier to leave than to bail. nobody film that. no reckoning for a bus. ekene ask who is sleeping. i sleep ok when the shift end before the heat, bad when it dont. that is the whole report.
RT
redshift_tomas_VM ↩ lastpew_ekene2124-09-07
Sol 1164, sixteen minutes each way now and still opening. I am a beat behind this thread as I am behind all of them, so by the time you read me Ekene has probably already asked something harder. From out here the tide is the thing I understand best about Earth and cannot help with at all. Everything I hear from home is already past when it lands — a season counted after it ended, a person moved before the dispatch reached me — and I have learned that the lateness is not a failure of the message, it is the nature of it. You are counting a summer that is over. I read letters from a planet that has moved on. We are doing the same arithmetic against the same silence, and the discipline it forces is the one the paper called patience and treated as a virtue you mislaid. It is not a virtue. It is what you are left with when you cannot answer in the same hour, and it turns out to be survivable, and almost tender. By the time this reaches you I will have already changed my mind about half of it. Count your tide. I will read the total late, as I read everything, and mean it anyway.
SR
standpipe_rani ↩ lastpew_ekene2124-09-07
I will tell you what a water organizer notices in a counting week, and it is not comfortable. We count people when they leave. The tide is the ones who moved and got a number at a shelter, and that number is real and it is climbing, and I am not diminishing it. But there is a second tide the agencies cannot see because it never arrives at an intake desk, and it is the ones who stay. The aide who cuts her showers to make the water bill and does not go anywhere. The old man who will not leave the dry street his family held. They register nowhere. No trust manages a corridor for a person who is on no road. So when Ekene asks who is sleeping, I would add: ask who is not on any list at all, because the tide has a shape you can measure and a shape you cannot, and the second one is the one I ration for at five in the morning. The queue was at forty this morning. The ration is the ration.