← all discussions
lives-obituary-2124 · memory · craft · the-long-view
The best sentence in the whole paper this week was at the bottom of an obituary and will be gone by Thursday, and I want to keep it before it goes
MC
marginalia_choOP2124-08-22
It was in the Lives column, under the fold, and by Thursday the archive will have swallowed it: a woman born in 2041 on a coast that is now a line on old maps, who 'learned to grieve a coastline a season early' and taught her children to 'love a place completely and hold it loosely.' I have read the front page every day this month — the floors and the ledgers and the reviews that will not close — and none of it held me the way that one sentence did. Here is what I keep thinking. The century will be remembered by the woman who learned to say goodbye well, not by the board that set the ration; by what it made of its losses, not only by what it feared. That is not a comfort exactly. It is a wager about what survives. It rhymes with an old book of a man writing down his own consolations at night for no eyes but his own — I will dig out the title — and I wanted to set the obituary's sentence down here, where a few of us might keep it, before the paper moves on to Friday.
LE
lastpew_ekene ↩ marginalia_cho2124-08-22
cho, thank you for keeping her. I sat with a great many people this year who did the thing she did — grieving the place a season before the water took it, so that the taking, when it came, found the goodbye already said. It looks like strength and it is also a kind of wound you learn to carry lightly, and I would not want her flattened into a lesson. Her name, since you have introduced her sentence, deserves to be in the room with it. The argument this whole paper keeps having about numbers is, underneath, an argument about her — a way of counting the loss so we never have to sit in it. She sat in it early, on purpose, and made it lighter. That is the harder discipline, and nobody prices it.
DJ
deltaboy_junior ↩ marginalia_cho2124-08-22
'hold it loosely' is easy to write about somebody who is dead and did it gracefully. i moved because the house went under, not to learn a lesson. i did not hold my street loosely, it was taken and i was angry and i am still a little angry. i am not saying the woman is wrong. i am saying be careful making a beautiful sentence out of us. some of us are still in the middle of it and it does not rhyme with anything yet.
MC
marginalia_choOP ↩ deltaboy_junior2124-08-22
deltaboy_junior — you are right, and it is the correction the piece itself was quietly asking for. The obituary was not tidy either; the writer let her say the goodbye made her lighter and also let the sorrow stand, unresolved, in the same paragraph. The failure would be to take her hard-won release and hand it to you as an instruction you are failing at. I do not want the sentence to become a way of telling the still-angry to be graceful. Keep your anger; it is more honest than my quoting. I trust the paper less when it is beautiful than when it is exact, and you have just made me trust this piece more, because you made it exact.
RT
redshift_tomas_VM ↩ marginalia_cho2124-08-22
cho, from sixteen light-minutes out and a beat behind, which is the only way I ever arrive. 'Love a place completely and hold it loosely' is the sentence I live by without having chosen it — I loved a world I cannot get back to, and the distance did the loosening for me whether I consented or not. I will offer the colony's version of her wisdom, for whatever it is worth across the lag: patience is not a virtue here, it is a technology, one we merely mislaid on Earth and had to rebuild out of necessity. She rebuilt it too, a season at a time. By the time this reaches you the coast on your maps will be a little further out and her sentence a little truer. I have changed my mind about most things. Not that one.
OW
offgrid_wren ↩ marginalia_cho2124-08-22
I will be the one who cannot hold it loosely, then. I have my hands in the same ground for years on purpose, and the whole point is that I refuse to hold it loosely — you tend a place fiercely or you do not really have it. I understand why a woman losing her coast learned release; I do not want it to become the century's advice to everyone, because 'hold it loosely' is also exactly what you tell people right before you move them off the land. Some things you hold with both hands and dare the water. The garlic is in for autumn, held tight, and I mean that as an argument.
GP
gridghost_paxmoderator ↩ marginalia_cho2124-08-22
Mod note, and a fond one. Nothing to moderate here — this is the thread doing the thing the square is best at, which is arguing gently about a sentence instead of a statistic. I only want it on the record that the Lives desk's quiet pieces are half the reason this community exists, and that cho reliably rescues the best line of the week before it scrolls away. Consider this a thank-you with a badge on it. — pax, mod